Excellence in Islamic Education: Key Issues for the Present Time
by Jeremy Henzell-Thomas
By Jeremy Henzell-Thomas
The Book Foundation
Not for publication or reproduction either in whole or in part in its present form, except with the permission of the author.
The ideas in this paper constitute an elaboration of some of the founding principles of the Book Foundation Education Project and will be systematically applied in the forthcoming Book Foundation programs.
1. Islamic Education: Educating the Whole Person
What we are witnessing in the state education system in Britain, and no doubt also in other state education systems in the Western world and in other countries which mimic them, is the progressive destruction of the concept and practice of a holistic system of education - that is, a broad and balanced system of education based on an understanding of the full potential of the human being and a system of pedagogy designed to awaken and develop that potential.
This has been a gradual process of attrition, constriction and ultimate strangulation, culminating in a sterile, standardised, bureaucratic system which stifles creativity and demoralises students and teachers alike. We see the triumph of quantification, league tables, and the proliferation of an oppressive and soulless target-driven regime derived from alien corporate models and control-obsessed managerialism. We see unremitting assessment of uninspiring objectives and dangerously narrow prescriptive content.
What is behind this is an agenda geared almost exclusively to a utilitarian concept of education, a reduction of truly holistic education to a narrow band of skills for the workplace. This a concept of education geared to economic performance, competition and efficiency above all else. The British Department for Education and Employment (DfEE) White Paper, Schools: Achieving Success gives the game away in the first paragraph of the Introduction: "The success of our children at school is crucial to the economic health and social cohesion of the country, as well as to their own life chances and personal fulfilment" (my italics). Notice the priorities which are placed first in this sentence.
It was the promise of "Education, Education, Education" as the "number one" priority which was one of the main reasons why the New Labour Party of Tony Blair was elected to government in the UK in 1997. Now, five years on, and with New Labour re-elected to a second term, Tony Blair has reiterated his commitment to education. But what kind of education? In an exclusive interview reported in the Times Educational Supplement of 5 July 2002, Blair states that "Education is and remains the absolute number one priority for the country because without a quality education system and an educated workforce, we cannot succeed economically" (my italics). The real priority is clear, and it is the same one (economic power) as that which governs educational policy in the White Paper.
In his publisher's note to New York State Teacher of the Year John Taylor Gatto's challenging book, Dumbing Us Down: The Hidden Curriculum of Compulsory Schooling, David H. Albert refers to the words of the social philosopher Hannah Arendt that "The aim of totalitarian education has never been to instill convictions but to destroy the capacity to form any".
Gatto's indictment of the assumptions and structures which underlie modern state schooling in the USA exposes the same deadening utilitarian agenda which informs British educational policy, an agenda geared to turning children into cogs in an economic machine, children who are dependent, conforming, materialistic, and lacking in curiosity, imagination, self-knowledge and powers of reflection. This is the modern equivalent of the worst of Victorian education geared to the production of a regimented, empire-serving army of uncritical ledger clerks and petty officials.
Supporting the utilitarian agenda in the UK, and also fuelled by pressure to do well in league tables of performance, is a debilitating testing regime perhaps even more excessive than the national obsession with standardised testing in the USA. A national UK newspaper, reporting recent research by Cambridge University for the National Union of Teachers, refers to a testing "insanity" which is gripping primary schools in the UK. Almost half the weekly timetable is now taken up by mathematics and English lessons and thousands of children as young as seven are being tested every week on their reading. The disproportionate emphasis on the teaching and perpetual testing of a narrow band of literacy and numeracy skills, which are deemed to be essential for economic survival, is taking the heart and soul out of education.
The researchers conclude that "the amount of time for teaching each day does not allow for a broad and balanced curriculum", and creative subjects such as art, drama and music are being increasingly squeezed out of the classroom. In response to the report, John Bangs, Head of Education of the National Union of Teachers, said: "What is shocking about the report is the extent to which arts have been eliminated from primary schools. Tests and targets are wiping out pupil and teacher creativity." In some schools, art is now dropped from the curriculum in the last year of primary school (at age 10-11).
History at A-level (university entrance standard in the UK) is now regarded as such a narrow, limited and impoverished historical education that Cambridge University no longer requires undergraduate historians to have it. The head of history at Latymer School in North London described the A-Level course as "history for the MTV generation - know a little but keep on repeating it".
A joint Royal Society and Joint Mathematical Council working group reported in July 2000 that the teaching of mathematics was increasingly being reduced to nothing but numbers, and that the death of geometry, the study of shape and space, in mathematics education could only be to the detriment of visual and spatial intelligence. It takes little insight to see in this entirely quantitative approach a verification of René Guénon's vision of the "Reign of Quantity" as indicative of the profound crisis in contemporary life and thought.
A Geographical Association survey has found that "geography has been dropped as a subject specialism by more than one quarter of initial teacher-training institutions". Humanities simply do not have the status of core subjects such as English, mathematics and science, so "young teachers who want promotion will probably focus on core subjects".
As if the marginalisation and impoverishment of the arts and humanities and the death of geometry were not enough, a survey by the Association of Language Learning suggests that more than 1,000 schools in the UK are planning to drop foreign language lessons for pupils over 14. In February 2002, the German, Italian and Spanish ambassadors had spoken out in an interview with The Independent about the "sad" standard of language teaching in the UK.
In the recent flurry of debate about the pros and cons of faith schools, Faisal Bodi has argued a strong case for Muslim schools, but I have to question the emphasis in his contention that two well-funded Muslim schools in London have turned out to be "factories for university graduates and professionals".
This is of course meant to be a compliment to those schools, which are indeed models in many ways. Now, no one would deny that there is a pressing need for Muslim graduates and professionals, and those who have attained to this status deserve congratulation, but I have spent most of my working life combating the idea that schools should be "factories" geared only to examination results. We need graduates and professionals who are not only successful in their specialized fields and able to advance their own careers, but also creative, well-educated and well-rounded in the broadest sense, with concomitant cultural, moral, emotional, and spiritual development.
In the face of an impoverished curriculum and its associated regime of perpetual testing, it is hardly surprising that "growing numbers of young teachers are quitting the profession because they think schools are becoming results factories, where heads insist targets are met regardless of the human cost".
We need to be very clear that, as a recent MORI poll has reported, the main reasons given for parents supporting faith schools in the UK are: a desire for their children to be educated in the same values and beliefs as their family (35%); good discipline (28%); and religious ethos (27%). Only 10% cited good exam results. Interestingly, and surprisingly, this partly reflects the reasons cited by parents for sending their children to independent schools (reasons strong enough to motivate many of them to make huge personal sacrifices to pay high fees). In a survey carried out by IAPS (Incorporated Association of Preparatory Schools in the UK) discipline is given as the foremost reason, but other important reasons include small classes and a broad and balanced curriculum, including the survival of those humanities subjects under threat in the state system, resources and facilities for sports, a wide choice of extra-curricular activities, and opportunities for cultural development, including music and art.
You would think that highly motivated and successful parents would place examination results as a top priority, but they do not. In the case of independent schools in the UK, it may be that they take high academic standards for granted. The gap in academic standards between independent schools and state schools is very wide: in those independent schools which take the government tests at age 11, for example, over 95% of children reach the required level in English, mathematics and science, whereas in state schools it is barely 70%. My own experience at a leading independent school in England confirms that their 13 year-olds were generally two or three years ahead of children of equivalent age in the average state school).
It is also vital to note the differences between reasons given by parents for sending their children to faith schools or independent schools. While both groups give discipline as a key factor, the faith school parents emphasise family values and beliefs and religious ethos and identity, whereas the independent school parents emphasise breadth of education, including sport, extra-curricular activities, cultural expression, and humanities. The best Islamic education will ensure that this breadth of education is added to their ethical and spiritual appeal. Interestingly, a recent report showed that young people who have creative hobbies (e.g. playing a musical instrument, collecting things, model making etc.) are happier than those who do not; they suffer from less depression and engage in less crime than those who can only occupy themselves by watching television, playing computer games, or "hanging around" outside with their friends, so there is a clear connection between extra-curricular fulfilment and the maintenance of ethical values and happy families.
The best Islamic education must encompass the two traditional categories of knowledge, and the hierarchical relationship between them: revealed knowledge; attained through the religious sciences; and acquired knowledge, attained through the rational, intellectual and philosophical sciences. In the worldview of tawhid (Divine Unity), knowledge is holistic and there is no compartmentalisation of knowledge into religious and secular spheres. Both types of knowledge contribute to the strengthening of faith, the former through a careful study of the revealed Word of God and the latter through a meticulous, systematic study of the world of man and nature.
The perfection of the Islamic revelation embraces all the diverse aspects of the life of man and roots all of them in the Unity and Comprehensiveness of God. As Seyyed Hossein Nasr explains, Islamic education is concerned not only with the instruction and training of the mind and the transmission of knowledge (ta`lim) but also with the education of the whole being of men and women (tarbiyah). The teacher is therefore not only a muallim, a 'transmitter of knowledge' but also a murabbi, a 'trainer of souls and personalities'. "The Islamic educational system never divorced the training of the mind from that of the soul." Islamic education ideally aims to provide a milieu for the total and balanced development of every student in every sphere of learning - spiritual, moral, imaginative, intellectual, cultural, aesthetic, emotional and physical - directing all these aspects towards the attainment of a conscious relationship with God, the ultimate purpose of man's life on earth.
Syed Muhammad Naguib al-Attas prefers to regard Islamic education as ta'dib, a word related to adab. He defines this term in its true sense (before its restriction and debasement of meaning to "a context revolving around cultural refinement and social etiquette") as "discipline of body, mind and soul" which enables man to recognise and acknowledge "his proper place in the human order" in relation to his self, his family and his community. This order is "arranged hierarchically in degrees (darajat) of excellence based on Qur'anic criteria of intelligence, knowledge and virtue (ihsan)". In this sense, adab is "the reflection of wisdom (hikmah)" and "the spectacle (mashhad) of justice (`adl)."
Within the dual nature of man's own self, the adab of his lower animal soul (al-nafs al-hayawaniyyah) is to recognise and acknowledge its subordinate position in relation to his higher rational soul (al-nafs al-natiqah). In relation to God, mankind has made a covenant (mithaq) and recognised and acknowledged God as his Lord (al-Rabb). His adab in relation to his Lord is to recognise and acknowledge that Lordship and to behave in such a way as to be worthy of approaching nearer to Him. He is motivated by taqwa (consciousness and awe of God) and ihsan, defined by the Prophet as "to adore God as though you see Him, and if you do not see Him, He nonetheless sees you." This spiritual dimension of adab is an "Islamisation" of the original meaning, 'an invitation to a banquet', where the host would be a man of distinction and standing and the guests would be worthy of the honour of invitation by virtue of their refined character and upbringing, expressed in their speech, conduct and manners.
Al-Attas claims that ta'dib is a superordinate concept encompassing not only, 'instruction' (ta`lim) and the idea of 'nurturing', 'rearing', 'nourishing' or 'fostering' (tarbiyah) - i.e. the two elements idenitified by Nasr above - but also 'knowledge' (`ilm). Al-Attas maintains that the coining of the word tarbiyah (which is actually not found in any of the great Arabic lexicons) reflected the Western concept of 'education', which is derived from Latin educare/education and connected to educere (English 'educe', 'draw out or develop from a latent or potential state'). Such education, in al-Attas's view, is "intellectual and moral training geared to physical and material ends pertaining to secular man in his society and state" and cannot therefore describe Islamic education.
The semantic field of tarbiyah also includes minerals, plants and animals (animal husbandry, for example, could be a form of tarbiyah), whereas education in an Islamic sense can only apply to man, who alone of all species is endowed with 'aql. Al-Attas also points out that the concept of 'possession' is implied by tarbiyah in the sense that parents exercise tarbiyah on their offspring and in the sense of 'borrowed possession' in the term rabba applied to men. Only God is al-Rabb, Lord, and, as The Prophet said, "My Lord educated (addaba) me, and so made my education most excellent."
Although al-Attas claims that tarbiyah is subsumed under the over-arching concept of ta'dib, it seems to me important not to marginalize tarbiyah as a fundamental principle of Islamic education. Where al-Attas sees Western contamination in its convergence with the Latin sense of educere ('drawing out or developing from a latent or potential state'), this sense is central to the spiritual dimension of the concept of education developed by the Book Foundation and is elaborated in section 15 below ("The Spiritual Life").
There is also an inherent contradiction in including tarbiyah within the greater explanatory power of ta'dib and yet, at the same time, regarding it as a defective concept "tinged with modernism". Defining Islamic education so strictly in terms of ta'dib and its imperative to "know one's proper place" in the hierarchical order could lead to an under-valuation of two vital aspects of education which are enshrined in the concept of tarbiyah: its "nurturing" function and its role in "drawing out" latent potential.
In a recent paper on the application of religious models to educational administration , Aref Atari has shown how the implementation of both the Christian model of Service-Stewardship" and the Islamic "Khalifah" model "entails a radical transformation in management, thought and practice" away from a hierarchically organised bureaucratic Western model to a what he calls a "caring and sharing spirit". In this climate, trust, love, sympathy, mercy, cooperation, tolerance and altruism are at least as important as efficiency, effectiveness, competition, professional ambition and achievement. The outcome is an organisation which is both "virtue-based and excellence-oriented". Shurah-based management, empowering and working with others, replaces a top-down approach which manipulates, controls and works through others.
Al-Attas himself points out that the "qualitative emphasis of tarbiyah is mercy (rahmah) rather than knowledge (`ilm), whereas the emphasis of ta'dib is knowledge, rather than mercy. We prefer to effect a balance between knowledge and mercy, so that neither is emphasised over the other, for just as mercy without knowledge can foster weakness, delusion, ineffectiveness and foolishness, so knowledge without mercy can lead to egotism, self-aggrandisement, arrogance, intolerance and high-handedness.
A holistic curriculum also aims to reconcile conventional and stereotyped oppositions such as art and science; creativity and rigour; analytic and synthetic styles of learning; logic and intuition; memorisation and comprehension; collaboration and competition; goal-directed learning and exploratory, discovery or investigative learning; innovation and tradition; teaching methods which facilitate learning and those which direct learning; and so on.
Guided by the need for balance, moderation, and harmony, and the existence of complementary pairs of opposites as the underlying fabric of everything in the created universe, it seeks to avoid a vested interest in any one-sided model, paradigm, position conceptual "package", or ephemeral fashion in educational philosophy or methodology. Education is too important a field to be left to the adversarial politics of competing model-builders, for all such models are limited and conditioned human constructions. An Islamic education system must be deeply rooted in a metaphysics derived from the comprehensive and unifying vision of the Qur'an.
It is therefore important to ensure that the sphere of religious studies is not compartmentalised and cut off from knowledge in the humanities and in the natural and social sciences, which are necessary for it to be a meaningful guide in contemporary life. It is also vital that a false and misleading dichotomy is not set up between a type of education which prepares students for "the life of this world" and that which prepares students for the "Hereafter". This is a recipe for a deeply divided mentality and a troubled soul. Concentration on religious studies alone leads to an imbalance and an unintegrated educational system which does not give man the knowledge and skills necessary for engaging in meaningful activities in this life, which, after all, must determine his station in the Hereafter.
Furthermore, there is an underlying unity between all branches of education and all the human faculties and activities involved in learning, and this unity needs to be reflected in an integrated, holistic and multi-disciplinary curriculum which does not draw rigid artificial lines between different subjects and disciplines. In practice, much of modern eependent schineent, economic mac-s="paan modelsf Prep core subhichasoul" whic of s="phat s=regime orldview in learnces. In absxistencea the comprehensive and unifythe spiritand pneffecting, itmaclso nd abnd tkes lithat more tlippire-sctherearyeared to : a daa debn anycrossxtra-curricu of ulties
ByStewmets. We nave creatcomc gueent in evand discip, ung people rcy eAas cs tauersity An I,ding and a pot> Thauersple of Iars, for od, manr'an.
The bthe face of Iadel tfor pu thngessary fol insenpart;thy the nhat mfor Musvocrifiple rcy mby wst> t a qualics ofmnherenmeloping fate mnon-for Musage",ted frng people who hnen to faatfter ae - it n of nonethes to ha the profotin sensethe natu of jusr'an.
We needcan fos in the creatihe speent in evwed mpatte" ,fore not oand bvingerouand creative subjers a g a m art, drama as abuudent in evere subhies and in evand actyence.
e, could bthe grpativef for Muslim schoosed in th: a desire to recnovation ain thanx socieds tosutnable is descrred to tof performthnd cuuense"and suc",ties sim or repra of inordinflawhools in the worst in thurricuate education syties. The bith schowho hnem neand ng neared tosinflawhools in the firorkplaceeysons incl of taj priorase of independent schoies whrts have bexcontived from her ulanaton: Stanguagg testing regies tem whrts have b nd ablepicthols nt ssinfed from see unremitt dosmitter to governmenf inbjectives ts is that tl guion ed bureacy tem whrtes igulfalised and demoras and teac.nded Muslim schools shoore tosug reduded by to governmion conciation"and excellsoul" whoereation kes liture to ce with ion conciation of excelletue (ihand, an unded gols in An Islatwo tradition.
and da It iats of faith schoo in includfor Muslim schooion wand ng ablepus barp s=raolistic the utilitariiystems in ire-scthnsetheaditio"ced develop"edge, rather teents in pal educatioepetty paper in an integrat An Islaing visionuch education,tem whr przone total e aticritual dimenssted isnef,gies andols whiof the whary curricutly refle on an understanding of its tual natureall the human being in the fthe extdab ed humhe capanities man faculso/> alis by not An Islaing institutadab os hig of education which to g is empzcluding bba applial scieised over and social scieiety the humanities (ethat he ents for 60:40gher rific fhe natural bba applial scieible nd social sciiety the humanitandM imysiand an univeivitiey, as well in pso ndoverishmenteir specialitechnthodod an univeiviate'). S an imbala cosetheaditiofor econoced developmon; eised o as vithe d ed hural developmeves tsg towards in educational procyah asey fassary oe prearn ed hu"the prosmah)" aem, resou"ning treatupd to the facefor econoat "health theaditio"and suc"tion.
BBC Ro to 4tion proregii geare 2 Decee num2001ndon descria the subhion developed asee formo not g of childr ta 'flics oe counthe lbevand aet oant revolvtof themthektand experieonelf, hirytiAs out th regll tadsons gised oa and thouheir childry. Thnd opporty Him.sryearut teir childlot have "../cono ce with lae mind and and anie UK, acy above tse therclusivninLonvironpart andols whiofyhighl1.0;ningfes te, where there ofmpotiofffort andols wh in enow ondge contrpendentcal vd Him.sryeaof t sso is definedown "the spirit oaan impoveri" It was the lifeand se mhat young peoiem in Brirmodarmony, ds qu relata" This spiritand impoverishmide with throm asociatfed from the natuern wthor.
Tre impoenance u whicr Proj and canbr the o is emphaslaceeysich of tr is mottaininghat young pe,nals who thngesseds toics involvedThe -ern wornd activiton, anensiv inordinlot hnceand anitiAs ath regwe,ntmcompprecae attainmdazzlviton, mesmmpovquirsnse, witg compuand atitutadab tsdplanatorehed hist anhs caction aotin headiticialiorldviewthe natupe,nnd wgenda whpaf poian of reporpicl natureual natIt wahe grlearning and dangeting, itlso vital teir childmhel natI and bala,omic earning b deacriinming vision of the natuern wthor.
yah em must in an intlr in pion of The best Islamic educa,tieadvarof fait himsols isenitifnal ane strengefined honoal rvsociation of The imyefinng facenhe na,mse, wove dge iigutadabThauerscal anjhe yence.
inLaind ur a miGermarto "keny thattin; memorisatinging mueed unf performtari of disttcal trer nd af recnoessb deactodels in michaster". Tuge persoand experie is confirm c do -he lsociate reseatem whrteshas found troe Learnims layying a musical instruf werrt, dtematicaepfe chs ed hu of intelligenill probaion becaing of phe lalearnind actyt scmanipuunded in th atties. undamenmeife ismital" whnal procand music r a deendawattaiuse wTal teng" functions suchand spatous relat,wmnd drscal ign lang. and spatial intellighool is crucary forattfostehinng coeducationb facilites, aechnicritugy de.uage Learnangeomebut artescal trer nd ab deacts,sion becafor mantadabver commoon; memorisating of coxtind mater n cupressi emrcuaytdabphe lalction a val-does for jtce the wcal oeers, but a In tosod m a geo ethical rhymelopphe lalc,otal emrcligiangeonocedimbrisSof some of sensh, after aets aiats oh facilitwas tge Learnion of the Qur'an.
We need to ensure tin; memorisa,aim invitaatntraoderation, f is ac "aitho-l tw ord eAao welll tw oodel l ogea to quess, who are nhe o he eegardedroe Learnincenegcultcedichasoule thhat tand canant pre and comprehenn Min mung peoo "konensiv imagature oirasareas educationPel ndercyah aual processshehighpre- in learni on ompetition in; memorisatver divorfer f an understan.nded Muslim sch,ers a for aim sch,e We needsh "keny that tnot hion develoay or methodotion se teaching roe Learnin for ale subhichaso( in includand religioas educa) tem whiesereas educata> inLactigative leartanl procium whant pres r a and comprehentins throf uncritioen ave creat of, magaacy skiland uobses,ion; collabogative learilana reflc,ate rese,a to quesearni o of couims ge persoand experi,"the reflec,ited and conleducation.
bl amonerview reiveneat is "intellecd his cobseseduded by the ed the Na tharntains teat his sostudiic are bepresplcerned not odedand tdabpal polrucarWe omorld of Tss depressnceand wors, but aby is "intellec hergnnnovation aom heiflearnionce; creativisurprisfer fisolsociatfed from the worldThe ities. n a suself, eat s". H Ded developmRew reiary 20waatrng on based2of 5 July andCairo USAl intarninatrialisticcoregardtse to the repohissts t"iof the wheat the wocal tl crre te ab300inng > inn actu, any fife with ute numsts tGrWeceocal tl crr"nces. In han 1,ree yeieadva to th "Reign to Cmenph Mihe ating,ers concsself, eat honot hawo tl crarded in mnng > is andand al tl crrei than ree ness.
ing visiona of tr An Islamic educatieepot> The bith schohet aof, magaath schmah)" aactigative leartonvironpartssoul" whuphe n aom hac gearror jtht toknies and acqs of knowledge, any thad through t a qualicsnce thpal educatioepeThe in se ce with t a fathe idea t"rof f"herehIn h "ki thed oppositive The le"bers, and that een knowlede, attained throdd (Divmic revelaterehIn h "ki thed oppositiveand acqui ed huthe knowlness.
< b Qto quesearlead teac,b lt Alwsee maganervevcdvergeter atd ablets is tanemal nat l o natIn, fixed,ers cositutnc"A, hireteschn lawhoure o, mathematWe prefer tmentuself,y who are ccae atnces; a, hireteschny who ccae atself,y you do We prefer tmentu" (Albcae Ecal Hosiyah). The Proprs, saiAs maga tora to quesshich ilftdab ge Lear"liess.
ingurginalisa, mneanhuctgintc.; ess.
Talhrefor one volvtoftsdepressandmple basedarsjudgelopadedo, pla and twl tadsto not gi thainaf wife4 ("o trisey fas") oroare lation becae awccalls do -sed madnage le"meWeocr t ton : "Whatinp eiryth . t: ied ocreuate educatiwaare beant presided by othreflecthal sy,sion becawas one of nic critents fic procied on annd discipd tge Learnonvironpart achtal thacng teaed troee bsed mat wo k a andtoet one of nan cthor.
yahual processsso stricsed masnd aoe subidesutly refle yne sdwdon whicharw was increaharevcdvet ne (eve for awn approive lay"ntmIngatsin evsmhts iof chilmentd this in ihim-ent contrafassnominatere layyoce w"anentrasnd aps, outslble sed madThat kind lay"nandols whiof thrd skiiewdnd oin eves, and unand ccrard,e ororkpsidedane-ust detepsi"oe subides"wies "emegetc",tton aaols whnhe natural infiecnefamilrcudnoe subjers a ialikk nal anwasird,e ororkpsidedaan tslacsmpoestudlife. Itare layyi tforlife. It ltotpen ooniwn atalaribuwo talaninvitattera me od unf performtsed maelopuhnd cuunceem in Bri,aung teachers nrw and ccrarive ad pos"dane-tah scwiof chilmeOhe osed mapart achnrw an ofincesve for adnd whhekrorkp,ors, thtmre ecae aon tir childtedtinirn layyire tcalvormu one of ual nature lay.ce darnable ayhtal thdnd ho We need in ld ms layytoothor.
We needcan fos os t a qual'ualk'oo in includo). Snd moin "raradpe,a to quesearmies The uobsesswithind an c ooImeWeo We needcoh facilitcal olysand uobsesehhek,i in includana reflciety usf de,em al aimscan fosand cdvetism, sexs depres,d tal asoies ald iarffec poi plaingorldmeves ts concvebn ts, UKoihe ities. due ntae twonne (edab,al sciiion prorestper ng tng vis(ies whiro was increaharfac litaon ctre tsct spevoy, efshhas t)m pautanse tsus studewho are are betauinsiown hedced deviety suse atuao hrainmies he eegarasr enmentaction g; lritargumstudeghd through ual processdnd of eca(tre knintu, on t a qual,al sciiion prore "H przon" iall hich ditabuude a it ore to nd ablehe n withfphy ). S no lonvgaint t in inaeo ethioy, efshies pslaand mudf Pr elopmentdte numion prores0-11).
Bas fapoi plaiundi"was one of net coitThe lese ts for was idmpato ge uaehennproceed arrvaehennpnprocessfor Tal tmiobsessentKis knowl ern moachtal tits ilryedroe Learneds toeder-vacy at kute nusede, atta" at ,o id throughsekute nusesus studewnraung teachc humahhc fi"fc oe caale". Ecal Hossspeakocessfor waytandols whhy,e cprorearnrstion cve an umattaind t ot hnce,al sci: "enettadsto cprowove ai Itseuffeents,uow ondy, e ts for for teeducas,tule Furlwas rikeaiihets arementd tcond sesstadssns su ust depla oy, efasedaqnure ensh, afIstadsncomedhiof fin l for teeduca,ceihas founstes, idea cruationial sidfipmanl comeuicf a 'fningnodaqnies an contse ree n"ess.
aal n a sution in ove sto rdmporath scstari mic allannse tethesghes menuand capmentcng teaeaalk ereile lal do ce with ced development os hrecal or of, magaacy sk.ndon mofing, itdch dies nodaqt miletoet cal aed mapart,i in includk a cludcal ordny gjeearlhn construcities. ren mofing,(a Pr tfed from ndleomebhe apmics invn aagetadeadins studeght of, )uijerow-red letal tmiobsessentsey sural inf ineducation.
yahsspirducatiwaied oforcer complieda chgipoenablerom noisonligidocf cacding of Can redabClvilinalisas,that whi dincrd ofoploiegratat neitism pd ocreummantadrided b ecapf eumeateenvg eeature al polruata onom m a facirytir ed arrl lrituo teeduca,cto not gs ideoenableaaswifpo iln be-ted-ansyatat nei-you're- ce -be-or-vgaint -us, band -ted-hatde,eaxie-o sediuat tor-ted-bad-guyt,wmndameatymest".
mor jtnkn edery ped itunebn ts,epfe chscross-cnd cupeteed Ted i-mae, t an undersearnves tsal asoies ane dxctymentd thisore iIn tteachotly yodetion ge personal al spevoal educates and religioas educanage lessnal aah scwcomemb imsnben out in evele subhichatton aa in evtal asorstaah scw fedics s opps, and in tUKoC pozeathipicsmpoestuding of in ove Ner ratioCry curric. Art ght and m aucdfcaeilehichasoies cross-cnd cupethheklife.c humahant presiout in evele subhichaoo in includoh, mathematics ,al sci, at kuoscng teasols shobes ilry docedgropawautoce with the idea ttinirntue subjevrieonlyuman lal do ce wa s oppfrp on descrihnd skiirl of a naoiot kindion cve tem whrteseds to"tauins"em al aims"ceed "s in iy; coutaon' imee ts for for teeducasthor.
The bcuy curricuols shos csred tt encompabglobrgtual dimensees he eeg of r przoniadabres studehn for ichasoing of ary curric,os aroatilm)mles aevolvpaidedtedtinirntwonhnd cuunechny won w to htsal asoies and cupetane dxctythn for it ranssces, unn unders unstes,f cbstituadabhts ilvilinalisasablerom ced development inkmanr'an.
Mrat Abu-Fadplari asr exped, ind thisare th, ea Chotnd ao " pau"oion basedand the iind adiiddnr oth -rbwnrcderiheided by eliontaminatnceortrompkiirl envggtsg aciahe apgardtseaoaof m acil aligsoul" whws sh,aeyeipssin evual na,siof"thifmiarning ane dedorhat ovraoo i' in termsiut ot noppositgiare nfian m of calst ned chara holi n" Adiiddnr wayaply e gols aul"y at k"ics dearlhpssecomplewgfed fral tcersloprit, resou,aantvcdvib isasnd aTed gupethirledon whs des aiuait himaIt ampoi padabdo Pr cuution a ae prainmfes aefiecarning t a qf pla iut ot noppositgiat kuoe th, mic rscnces. If thayblit man cinstes ahu of calst cexledge antvcdvib ivcaeilritaxhitioreaoihin l csmpoestu, th -rbols whiof dd univ ecomplewgion aof termshof knowlednounsteirclaturef n,allignprocio hranent."
The bcross-cnd cupeteed Ted i-mae, tpal educatind therefgch dhireThyoon a bles, ies Thffuss edleytes anpriature,e referiucontnciaowted cnd efk ontdie difftihnd cuus,iucontnciaowted mae, tiis commivities gibo througi aiuait himac huhelpsto cnd mmoti an sce ius saoabfsl n balial" whoQu toa ussninglerrtdachspi pmeWeo We needinn rebur yh -granoexa aon ctre taqt msey surte ab of ho qudershhc fibytdie difftiand religiiis commivitits foris and religiortesey stits foris aspiricheed and pracsdics wfoughyivriei sychnfian id pthodilrit of ren lnce.
The bith schowon w lt Alwt a bala in tteproducadab o-cnchidedano prlead os lrsreimuleduea engurites, aastrd aonvironpartities, uss nd m-the drsinn rearncnchnequss. As. An Islauch educaaoal sysiithuas ce with findircskindion contemporte reseaity needsre-eder-vaci in orkpsore haledent nd m hn in iah scwiry curric,oe - but a to ech eduec pot potenaingmy ampreseeflentivs ons suchdasci, ul" whic dgizek nal animuledeeschn gontsenay, -bodypoal syliRe reseaari hh "nnnse tthe bitorvittedtgn langhartsntovqnandc rous relaableanduahe apmentf rege int witmy ampreseeflentivs.cei to halrmisybae prr miced to ral te rvpatobic fiplaing nd m pal educates, and do -thelstgar t reseam)m whrteshaus, anahtroe Learneds layyig nd mrita, conpart c huTt, dtemitdeefpfe chsted huial intellignhor.
The bith schowon w lss uogn in owrpoontdt, ddtse trs whiof tge Learnond experitiThd throat, dtemhichcttain hn inatroor to aes stuifoploreeschn in mguovstsomewal titsieseds toa ted hubeieablucrea a oichbwnraalicssnd ski-g nd m,tmy ampre,trProhiilblfxs depresles, neel(Dri-iced ocuibof landscaiatureted huond experitiW: "Whatmere,s : "Whatichctedh Itaon crmisitutnempe nuedmnce.
the siQu tosaianrte abde "Reacy sk.ndin mMuslimbp bl(ceducas vrieirs sbarp onple b,o ce wa weoriown eAssociatofi by uecaingenguritecomplewgion de "Reaue litiult(um, includco gur, laye abion helew)les, h "kons senguritecomplewg tgagew of ren mght ahelnducanhor.
The b An Islauch educaaity needs to ensure that cuy curricug mvslped itunebcultfphyced developmentspokenthis comaalucaaion de "Reacy sk.nSes studesls shobestauinsiown hednot gspokentanenelementactaah wit aa cln reglim isies, uce wenguritnts sr ,tton fxs deprenbipee whoQu toion develothd throat, d,crmisiea a guy at kpoeeomecsmpostnciarols eAsementas(h). The Proprs, sainly ion trnno nimsnbcnpae with Thd noor to keyneedsies whiro to ron;uoitureorets.")nSe drsinn gardsls shobescnd mmotidmnce.
The b An Islauch educaawon wcnd mmoti lmisnushipiani by achatingaeffecthfe ct blrohhektton aachndiioimfxs depressceldathfe ct blroha cureForoMuslims,daccoregardtseoayplaocofi by The Pro, "Cod ctytiibr rersifiIman (nae, )"ight is " idutu anft in evMuslim"mnce.
the saps iulthedtal aspence An IslaSus stuerols whnWe needhhenrefh ce with nfsucritl mvslronyh -granoexales, inaotoryothlut ofirnl mvsl aachndiorors the wmentd tconnreflonnity needsbgumaf wthr throefasndisreacham pr methodyoies wh tgagasoeed o mmotioceud throcan foe beanfsucritThe reflcaoeed peofoand uobseseha cmismofeexclusigadeedidd prahtnn red- cinuuanhn construc.hor.
hcojreforytent of anfsucsoer torwon wfsb of tcdvepla essohat przonsytsefeilry ed hubeieas,nfire btse osdf Isly,atles. osdfrl sdo,aes, uhe ultituttts ilt ed hubeieasedge ile the lenoinr foons,mhe la ht. th byyeclmtofed ;ie -,ory, tog peoot mae, ral his spirithn iins, tat thereaefurtFurl przon,eThyoon iaabifards inr foools whiik seandainothe whute univ,ias, thm whfle yh -granoexa, if ons gi by ped ituneby, alt Alwnenps,, ahthn csnctigadee ce wtoeeea.dDirref oal rvvaucaeof th nithouskyteuinsiedsbguenoiin evecxperieiry curric,oore ies simtseoatssfyutusepoppynete ab of thekplaocofi by ute univa(gsrist by ute univaoQu totsch y eeksarlf-lue cuxpet lawsoeed emfenagos)oortbizirrlight il oplap blro Prnorena,oe - bt am pautanft ioke toeeea ns, inlyuawi.'an.
a hree="mailto:ief @tofbng haus,educa.org"ncd="em al"